Gary Neal Hansen

Theology. It's good for you.

  • About
    • Speaking
    • Contact
    • Home
  • Books
    • Love Your Bible
    • Christmas Play
    • Kneeling with Giants
    • Review Crew
  • Library
    • Join
    • Login
  • Blog
  • Lenten Prayer Class log in
    • Lenten Prayer Class Info
    • Class Info: Your First Sermon
      • Your 1st Sermon — Course Login
    • Advent Lectio Divina Class Info!
      • Lectio Divina Class Log In
    • “Pray Like a Reformer” Class Info
      • Pray Like a Reformer Login
  • Christmas Play
  • Love Your Bible
  • Kneeling with Giants

The Paradoxical Presence of Christ (Heidelberg Catechism Q47)

August 26, 2016 by Gary Neal Hansen 4 Comments

Nik Wallenda, cc by Jennifer Huber-SA2.0
Nik Wallenda, cc by Jennifer Huber-SA2.0

A couple weeks ago I was reflecting on a much-neglected biblical teaching: the ascension of Christ. We may neglect it because there is a conundrum in the ascension: the puzzling, if not outright paradoxical, presence of Christ.

Ascension vs. Presence

The last scenes of Jesus’ earthly ministry are emphatic about two completely opposite things:

  1. Jesus promised to be with us always, even to the end of the age. (Matt. 28:20)
  2. Jesus left, ascending into heaven. (Mark 16:19, Luke 24:51, and Acts 1:9)

Most of us, most of the time, don’t fret about that too much. Both sides seem true.

  1. We have some kind of sense that Christ is active within us or around us. That matches up with the promise in Matthew.
  2. We don’t actually see Jesus in person. That matches up with the Ascension.

If there is a paradox between those two points, we are pretty much over it.

Until we aren’t.

If you think about the Ascension, the absence of Christ may start to bug you. If Jesus went up to heaven, isn’t he just … gone?

Are we fooling ourselves when we think about Jesus being with us

  • in our hearts
  • in the Lord’s Supper
  • or active in the world?

The writers of the Heidelberg Catechism (the much-loved Reformed summary of biblical theology I’ve been blogging about, off and on, since it’s 500th anniversary in 2013) comes right out and asks the question:

47 Q. But isn’t Christ with us until the end of the world
as he promised us?


A. Christ is true human and true God.
In his human nature Christ is not now on earth;
but in his divinity,
majesty,
grace,
and Spirit
he is never absent from us.

It was an important point for Reformation-era Protestants, actually.

Lutheran vs. Reformed

At the Marburg Colloquy of 1520, when all the Protestants tried to come together, their differences came down to how they thought about the Lord’s Supper — and the Ascension.

  • Martin Luther looked to the words of Jesus at the Last Supper, “This IS my body,” and said that it was a promise: Jesus is really, physically present in the Eucharist.
  • Ulrich Zwingli and others on the Reformed side looked at the Ascension and said Jesus’ body is in heaven. We can’t have him physically present, even at the Eucharist. We should listen instead to Jesus’ command: “Do this in REMEMBRANCE of me.”

The Heidelberg Catechism came more than a generation later, in 1563. The writers were walking a tightrope:

  • They were trying to establish the Reformed understanding of the faith.
  • They were in a territory legally obliged to follow Lutheran theology.

They didn’t want to fall all the way in either direction. Or better to say, like any tightrope walker they had to keep equal weight on both sides to stay steady.

So they looked at the incarnation in a way that was familiar to readers of John Calvin, and a bit controversial among Lutherans — though its roots go all the way back to the Greek theology of the ancient Alexandrian tradition.

The Incarnation of the Logos

Now hang in there with me…

In the early centuries, Greek-speaking theologians were delighted to see that John 1 said that “In the beginning was the Word” or “Logos.” The Logos, said John, actually was God, and through the Logos all creation came into being.

A reader of Greek philosophy would know that the LOGos was that thing that made creation orderly, rational — LOGigcal.

The Logos wasn’t just a simple word that was spoken. The Logos is what made all of creation make sense. The Logos kept it all hanging together.

Without the Logos, the whole universe would tumble into chaos and nothingness.

So what about when the Logos became human in Jesus? Jesus was the incarnation of the Logos. Does that mean that outside Jesus there was no Logos?

Ah… there’s the actual paradox. A much bigger paradox than the Ascension.

  1. Jesus, walking around in the flesh, was truly, and fully the Logos.
  2. But all the while, the Logos was maintaining the entire universe.

In other words, the Logos was

  • not constrained
  • not contained
  • not limited

to the measure of Jesus’ body.

The Logos continued to order the whole of the universe outside Jesus even when the Logos became incarnate as Jesus.

The paradoxical presence of Christ

The Ascension sort of reverses the original paradox:

  • Christ’s human flesh ascended into heaven.
  • Meanwhile, the divine Logos, Jesus, remains present with us — and will remain with us even to the end of the age.

Do you find Jesus’ ascension and presence with us paradoxical? Helpful? I’d love to hear your thoughts in the comments.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Filed Under: Bible, Heidelberg Catechism, Theology Tagged With: Ascension, extra calvinisticum, heidelberg catechism

Hungry for a better way to go deeper with God?

If you enjoyed this post, subscribe to my weekly(ish) newsletter -- I'll send you links to every new article, as well as updates on new projects. Just click the orange button.

Subscribe!
As a thank you, I'll send you the ebook version of my book Love Your Bible: Finding Your Way to the Presence of God with a 12th Century Monk. It's a modern introduction to an ancient, prayerful, Christian approach to Scripture.

Comments

  1. Fr. Dustin says

    August 28, 2016 at 4:30 PM

    It seems, in some sense, that a major part of the answer is still missing!

    The Road to Emmaus story presents the same problem. Jesus is walking with two friends, who don’t recognize Him. Even when Jesus opens up Scripture and shows how His incarnation, death, and resurrection is in line with everything Scripture says, they still don’t get it. Then, in the breaking of the bread, they recognize Him, but He disappears from their site!

    The same happens in the Orthodox Divine Liturgy, the Catholic Mass, or other liturgical traditions. First is the opening up of Scripture (Liturgy of the Word), which usually includes the homily. Then comes the Eucharist, the breaking of the bread – Christ is presented to us (His Body and Blood), but then what do we do? We consume Him! In doing so, He disappears from our sight!

    But the question isn’t, “Is Jesus with us?” It should be, “Where is he?”

    The answer: if, in consuming the Eucharist, we are united to Christ, He doesn’t disappear because we *become* Christ! Indeed, the faithful who are gathered *is* the Body of Christ. We can’t see Him, simply because He’s now us! Complete union.

    So, is he *with* us? Well, yes, but mystically we have become Christ and His Body continues to walk the earth.

    (This is why the Church is our Mother – just as St. Mary birthed Christ, so the Church births Christ when we are baptized, chrismated, and partake fo the Eucharist.)

    Reply
  2. Gary Neal Hansen says

    August 30, 2016 at 7:28 PM

    Thanks Fr Dustin!

    I’ve not heard that comparison before. Good food for contemplation.

    Reply
    • Fr. Dustin says

      August 31, 2016 at 8:56 AM

      P.S. Is there a way to get replies to my comments e-mailed to me, or at least some sort of notification? Thanks!

      Reply
      • Gary Neal Hansen says

        August 31, 2016 at 9:29 AM

        At present, no, alas. I’ve put in the request to the people who host the website. Since it isn’t WordPress I’m unable to just add the relevant plugin. I’ve asked for this function before, so I’m hoping it is in the pipeline.

        Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Theology. It’s good for you.

I'm a Church historian by trade. My writing, speaking, and teaching explores the Christian past to equip today's disciples. Join me here for regular posts on the best of theology, spirituality, community, and ministry. read more…

Recent Posts

  • A Children’s Sermon on Matthew 21:23-32
  • A Children’s Sermon on Matthew 20:1-16
  • A Children’s Sermon on Matthew 18:15-20
  • A Children’s Sermon on Matthew 13:24-30, 36-43 — Wheat and Weeds
  • A Children’s Sermon on John 14:15-25

Search the site

Need a new and manageable way to dig into Scripture?

Find out how it can be a joy again--or maybe for the first time. Love Your Bible: Finding Your Way to the Presence of God with a 12th Century Monk is a modern introduction to an ancient, prayerful, Christian practice called lectio divina. Click the button to subscribe to my weekly(ish) newsletter with all my new articles and announcements. As my way of thanking you, I'll send you the ebook version for free.

Get my book!

Archives

Let’s connect on social media…

  • Facebook
  • Google+
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter

Search the site

  • Community for Mission
  • Letters to a Young Pastor
  • Christianity as a Second Language
  • Role Models for Discipleship

© 2023 garynealhansen.com · Rainmaker Platform