What is faith, really?
Some will tell you it is a leap into the dark — jumping into the unknown, off a proverbial cliff, and hoping that Someone will catch you. For Jesus that wasn’t faith; that was “tempting” or “testing” God, and he wouldn’t do it.
Or when we need faith to pray effectively people say “Just believe!” as if we could throw a switch and make it so. You know: I see someone who is sick, and I believe she is dying; I throw the switch; and by just choosing to believe it, I supposedly have faith that God will heal her. It sounds like I’m supposed to lie to myself.
The Heidelberg Catechism has a great section answering the question “What is true faith?” It is one of my favorite passages — Question 21 (Click here if you want to download the Catechism and see this passage in full. Or click here if you want to get my brief study guide to this widely used Reformed teaching tool.)
Real faith, the kind of faith Scripture says is so important, has two parts — or subtly three:
1. Faith holds as true what Scripture reveals to us.
2. Faith trusts that what Scripture promises in the Gospel applies to me personally.
Take just part of this as the whole and it can go terribly wrong. It is easy to find Christian people for whom the whole of faith is believing the Bible. It is also easy to find non-Christian people who tune Christians out because we seem to say Scripture teaches as fact what they think is contrary to science and history.
To really get the first part of Heidelberg’s faith (belief in what Scripture reveals) we actually need the help of the second part (wholehearted trust that the Gospel promises apply to us). And to get either one, we need the help of God. That is the third subtler part of faith:
3. Faith is something created in us by the Holy Spirit.
We don’t manufacture faith as trust or get intellectually convinced of the facts. God gives faith as a gift.
Luther led the way in teaching that faith means trust — interpersonal trust between us and God. We hear God make promises to forgive and love us in Christ, and we trust God to be true to his Word.
Once we trust God all of life is on a new footing — but we only come to trust God personally when the Holy Spirit does the inner work, overcoming our brokenness and fear and doubt. That then makes it possible for us to figure out what Scripture is really revealing and believe it as true — and we find the core message is about who God is, why we are a mess, and how God in Christ unmesses us.
Faith isn’t a leap into the dark. Faith is a leap into the light. We understand our problem and God’s solution as revealed in Scripture — by the light of the Holy Spirit. We trust in goodness of God and his promises in Christ — with the transforming help of the Spirit.
How do you hear people using the word “faith” in ordinary conversation?
In your own experience of faith how do “believing the Bible is true” and “trusting the promises of the Gospel” relate to each other?
dbuck says
January 24, 2013 at 4:12 PMYes! I’m all over that third subtler part!!
Gary Neal Hansen says
January 24, 2013 at 4:33 PMHey, Donald, great to hear from you. What do you hear in your emergent community conversations about things like this? When they talk about faith, what seems to be the focus?
Natasha @ Christian Mom Thoughts says
January 24, 2013 at 5:32 PMHi Gary, Great post. This is a topic near and dear to my heart – because I am an overly analytical type A person who finds faith extremely hard! My head and heart battle it out. I do believe that ultimately we have to be convicted by the Spirit since there are no certain answers. I really, really wish it weren’t that way. 🙂
As for the Bible being “true,” this is something I wrote about recently on my blog (perhaps you’ll enjoy the post: http://christianmomthoughts.com/is-the-bible-true-part-i-the-problem-with-saying-the-bible-is-true/). I think many Christians don’t consider what they mean when they are saying the Bible is “true”. I’m hoping through my blog to help people better understand what truth means – and doesn’t mean – in light of the difficulties non-believers often point to.
Gary Neal Hansen says
January 24, 2013 at 5:52 PMThanks, Natasha! I look forward to reading your post.
You make an excellent point about people’s confusion about what it means for the Bible to be true. Early Reformed theological texts like Heidelberg Catechism (others explicitly, Heidelberg implicitly) tend to focus on what the Bible says about its primary subject matter — it is a book intended to teach us about God, about humanity from God’s perspective, and about how God in Christ intervenes to bring salvation. The problems moderns have in light of, say, evolution or other fruits of scientific and historical research were not their problems since they are later developments. But I suspect that they would have rolled their eyes a bit at arguments about the Bible in relation to matters outside the Bible’s focus — which is, in their understanding, Christ.
J K Thompson says
January 26, 2013 at 11:15 AMDo not be afraid. Our God invites us into light.
Joe Pruett says
February 19, 2015 at 6:31 AMFaith, I truly like the thought process of trust to go with faith. For it is by having trust in God that we can have faith. This may not mean what we want to happen will occur, but if believe Paul in Romans 8:28 then we can know that whatever is occurring is in God’s plan and that is a great place for us to be.